Customer ReviewsforMystic Stamp Company, Inc.

I cannot get this company to stop emailing their ads and catalogs. I ordered 1 coin for my mother in law and have now been doomed to this never ending cycle catalogs and ads. I would not wish this on an enemy. Thankfully they have stopped mailing the junk coins and wanting out of this world $$ for something that was never ordered. I just want to be done with them and not have my maibox filled with their junk mail.

Contempt is the only word I can use to explain my feelings of the Mystic Stamp Company. Their blatant mail fraud practices in the 1960s directed toward children who read comic books, I was 12 or 13 years old when I found a add in a Captain America comic book #131 that stated I could buy 225 stamps for 10 cents by The Mystic Stamp Company. no fine print just 10 cents. To a child that looked like a good deal so I sent a dime to the Mystic stamp company expecting to receive $225 stamps for 10 cents they made true on their advertisement and sent me 225 stamps. however after 6 or 7 weeks I received a notice from a collection agency they had turned me in to demanding I pay nearly $4 for the stamps in addition to the 10 cents I had already paid. you have to understand these stamps were canceled foreign stamps tore out of envelopes that were basically worthless. nevertheless there was no indication at the time of purchase they would charge any additional fees. when I was 13 years old I received .25 cents a week allowance from my Dad for chores. $4 then in today's money is equivalent to nearly $30 as a child I was intimidated and had to get a job working in bean fields to pay them ********. I have no respect for people who take advantage of children especially Liars cheaters and mail fraud felons, Iam sure they've been called this and much worse many times through the years, I have friends who are lawyers today that would love to take a case on like this but it looks like this statute of limitations of run out on these ******** but if I find evidence that they're still perpetrating this fraud upon children I will definitely go for their throats in the legal way. 0 stars or -0 stars worthless beyond any measure of any standard

This is by far the best company that anyone would be proud to deal with. Not only do you receive the best customer service but any answer you may have is answered promptly but they respond to you like they care and where to go to find exactly what you're looking for. They send me emails with pictures of stamp's and the story behind it. Try this company out and you won't regret it.

Worst company to deal with. Cheats and liars. Would never deal with them again. Should get NO stars.

I assume that people generally only file reviews when they are displeased with a business. However, I have always been extremely pleased with the service provided by Mystic Stamps. I've ordered several hundred stamps from them over the years and always received exactly what I ordered - except on those occasions when I received BETTER than what I ordered! When you get a stamp that's over a 100 years old and they describe it as having "small flaws," you can rest assured that you're getting a stamp in really good condition (and personally I've never been able to find the flaws). Also, there have been several instances in which they have upgraded my order of a used stamp without additional charge to a mint stamp when they did not have a used stamp in stock! My orders have always been accurate, arrived in a timely manner, and been carefully packaged to protect the contents.

I bought some albums from them and what they sent me was not advertised. I will never do business with them again.

Spiteful practices sending junk mail usps several days per week.

I love this company I always buy all of my maxi cards from here…my 1 and only problem is that whenever I order a Certo amount.. once I receive my order I find that it’s less then what I ordered but they do refund me my money for the amount…but still, if you are limited, then at least put it on your website letting us know the limited stock….oh and also, y’all should let us know like emailing us to say that we will only be receiving this amount of product so we won’t have to end up getting confused why we only received 3 or 5 cards instead of the 10 that was originally ordered. Thank you, I’ll still be purchasing though

I appreciate your website as well as your catalogues via US Mail. Mystic is always prompt with communications (i.e., Internet & Snail Mail). I hope you will be able to identify the 3 Cents Washington post marked June 25, 1865, which includes the text PROPRIETARY below picture of Washington. I sent an ID request on July 4, 2022 at 1:00 AM PST. Thanks!