Business ProfileforCustom Offsets LLC

I ordered 4 tires from custom offsets on June 20th, 2024. These tires were for rims I already ordered from them (which did not fit the car they were bought for although guaranteed by custom offsets) but thats beside the point. I selected the rim that I owned and it autofilled I and ordered 4 tires based off of the dimensions and specs of the rim for a perfect fit. Two of the tires fit as described, however 2 do not fit as they were described to fit. This usually would be no problem, I would simply return and exchange, no hard feelings. However when I contacted them, they are trying to charge me a $175 fee, and it is my fault for not checking they didnt fit. However on their website, it literally filters out tires that do not fit the selected rim, however these tires were not filtered out. Below is a photo of the exact rims and tires being ordered in a compatible package. The customer support representative keeps saying I shouldve checked the fitment guide for my car or one doesnt exist, but this is not the issue. This has nothing to do with my car. This is an issue with the products they falsely advertised and sold me. Im not asking for anything ridiculous from them, just for them to correct their error and accept the brand new never used tires, that still have the sticker on them, that they falsely advertised back without charging me a ridiculous fee.